Fundamental limits and trade-offs in negative feedback control

Johan Paulsson

Harvard University, Boston

The conventional wisdom on negative feedback in biology is that it checks spontaneous fluctuations and provides homeostasis to external changes. We challenge this view by showing how different sources of variation - spontaneous low-copy fluctuations, feedback noise, and external changes - are suppressed according to incompatible principles, generating frustration trade-offs where reducing one type of variation amplifies another. The trade-offs produce physical limits to noise suppression that can be formulated in terms of the biological constraints. We further show how approaching the limits can require exotic features that have been widely overlooked in biology, including counteracting feedback loops, accelerating gains, and non-Markovian molecular memory.

Back